Comparison Summary
For portable, battery-free solo practice, the Caldwell Claymore Solo is the most adaptable choice: its pedal tensions and releases the arm, it folds, and it handles standard, midi and mini clays as singles or doubles. You still load the next target yourself. The larger Caldwell Claymore trades that compactness for a 50-target magazine and step-operated throws without a battery. (caldwellshooting.com)
For sustained shooting, Champion’s WheelyBird 3.0 pairs a 60-target magazine with a documented 1.5-second cycle; its included release is a corded pedal, not the optional wireless remote. Do All Outdoors’ Flyway 80 holds 80 targets and includes both a pedal and wireless remote, though its listed 2.5-second recycle is slower. The original 50-target WheelyBird remains a sound middle ground if its two-second cycle and corded pedal meet your needs. These are published specifications, not interchangeable measures of flight quality. (championtarget.com)
Smaller sessions have distinct options. The 27-pound Do All Outdoors FireFly packs into an included bag but holds 25 clays; the Fowl Play holds 50 and offers angle adjustment but still needs a separate 12V battery. For manually set presentations, Champion’s waist-high SkyBird tripod, Do All Outdoors’ ground-spiked Backyard Clayhawk and Champion’s simple High Fly string-release trap suit different setup preferences. (doalloutdoors.com)
Buying Guide
Sizing and Capacity
Capacity is the number of clays a feeder holds, not the number a machine launches at once. The Flyway 80 holds 80; the WheelyBird 3.0 holds 60; the original WheelyBird, Caldwell Claymore and Fowl Play hold 50 each. The FireFly’s 25-target feeder is a reasonable exchange for its smaller carry format. The Claymore Solo, SkyBird, Backyard Clayhawk and High Fly suit deliberate manual sequences rather than extended auto-feed runs. Also check the size of the clays already in your bag: Champion documents 108mm standard and 110mm international targets for both WheelyBird models, while Caldwell identifies standard, midi and mini compatibility for the Solo. Do not assume that compatibility transfers to another model from the same brand. (championtarget.com)
Feature Tradeoffs
Release control is the clearest solo-shooting distinction. The Claymore Solo tensions and fires with one pedal press; the larger Claymore uses foot-operated cocking and release while feeding from its magazine. The WheelyBird models and Fowl Play supply corded pedals, whereas the Flyway 80 includes both its corded pedal and a wireless remote. WheelyBird 3.0 remote compatibility does not mean a remote is included. For different presentations, the Solo can launch singles or doubles, while a manually adjusted angle changes a planned flight path rather than randomizing each throw. The Flyway 80’s wobbler adapter plate does not include the wobbler kit. Choose that extra mechanism only if changing presentations automatically is worth the additional equipment. (caldwellshooting.com)
Best For, Avoid If
| Profile |
Recommended Product |
Why It Fits |
Avoid If |
| Solo shooter who travels light |
Caldwell Claymore Solo 4002777 |
Folding, 15-pound foot-operated trap handles multiple clay sizes and singles or doubles without a battery. |
You want a magazine that feeds a long run of targets. |
| Frequent shooter who wants fast auto-feed sessions |
Champion WheelyBird 3.0 40927 |
60-target magazine, documented 1.5-second cycle and included corded pedal. |
You need wireless control included or cannot supply the specified battery. |
| Shooter seeking magazine capacity without electric power |
Caldwell Claymore 1122187 |
50-target magazine and foot-operated launches remove battery planning. |
You would rather carry the lighter Claymore Solo or avoid stepping for each throw. |
| Shooter who wants included wireless release |
Do All Outdoors Flyway 80 FW80 |
80-target feeder comes with a stated 300-foot remote and a corded pedal. |
You prioritize a faster listed recycle or a smaller machine to transport. |
| Shooter carrying an auto-feed trap between locations |
Do All Outdoors FireFly FF550 |
27-pound body and included bag make it the more packable automatic pick. |
A 25-target feeder would interrupt your sessions too often. |
| Manual-trap user who prefers a waist-high setup |
Champion SkyBird Tripod 40906 |
Tripod, string release and one-way clutch distinguish it from ground-spiked traps. |
You want foot-pedal release or automatic feeding. |
Key Specs to Compare
Read cycle time alongside magazine size: Champion documents 1.5 seconds for WheelyBird 3.0 and two seconds for the original; Do All Outdoors lists 2.5 seconds for the Flyway 80 and FireFly. Those figures describe the machine’s recycle interval, not how rapidly you should shoot. Manufacturer documentation gives WheelyBird 3.0 a range of up to 75 yards, while its product listing says 70 yards; use the exact-model manual as the reference and treat either figure as a stated limit, not a guaranteed flight distance. The manual also specifies a 12V, 30Ah battery, with deep-cycle type recommended. Check voltage, capacity and clay dimensions for the exact model rather than borrowing specifications from another WheelyBird. (championtarget.com)
Setup and Handling Considerations
Plan the trip from vehicle to firing position, not just the space a trap occupies in storage. The 15-pound Claymore Solo folds; the 27-pound FireFly has an included bag; the WheelyBird machines and Flyway 80 have wheels. Caldwell describes the larger Claymore as 35 pounds, while its product listing gives an item weight of 39 pounds, so allow for the heavier figure when lifting it. The Backyard Clayhawk’s included spikes need suitable ground, while the SkyBird stands on a tripod without staking. Establish a stable position, keep everyone clear of the throwing arm and target path, and follow the exact model’s instructions for loading, uncocking and safe access. A long pedal cord or remote does not make placement or shooting-area clearance optional. (caldwellshooting.com)
Maintenance and Longevity
Match upkeep to the mechanism you buy. A manual spring trap avoids battery planning but still depends on sound mounting and moving parts; inspect and use it as its instructions direct. An auto-feed trap adds battery connections, a feeder and an arm mechanism to account for when packing and putting it away. Do All Outdoors identifies model-specific replacement parts, including BY34 manual-trap parts and parts for its automatic traps; that is useful if a component needs replacing, but verify the exact part and model before ordering. Champion’s WheelyBird 3.0 manual identifies a replaceable throwing-arm flight rail. Never reach into an arm’s path to clear a target: use the manufacturer’s shutdown and safe-release procedure first. (doalloutdoors.com)
Reliability Signals
Favor exact-model documentation over a shared product-family name. Champion provides separate manuals for WheelyBird 40909 and WheelyBird 3.0 40927, with different magazine sizes, cycle times and battery guidance. Caldwell’s descriptions likewise distinguish the single-load Claymore Solo from the 50-target Claymore. Look for an operating manual, clearly identified controls and model-matched replacement components before treating an accessory as compatible. A warranty label in a product listing is less useful than checking the manufacturer’s current terms for the specific item; the larger Claymore’s listing fields disagree on warranty length. None of these signals guarantees service life, but they help you understand what equipment you are buying and how it is supported. (championtarget.com)
How to Compare Reviews
When reading owner accounts, match the exact model, power source and shooting routine to yours. Feedback on a WheelyBird 40909 does not establish how a WheelyBird 3.0 handles, and an account of a Flyway 80 fitted with an optional wobbler describes a different setup from the base machine. For the FireFly, look for details about carrying its 27-pound body and refilling the 25-target feeder; for the Claymore Solo, look for comments about pedal use and loading one target at a time. Give more weight to accounts that name the clay size, battery setup and number of throws in a session than to broad praise without those conditions. Treat a reported flight distance as dependent on the setup, not a universal result.
Common Mistakes
Do not buy an automatic trap and assume the operating battery is in the carton: the FireFly, Fowl Play and Flyway 80 specify separately supplied 12V batteries, and WheelyBird 3.0 calls for a particular 12V, 30Ah specification. Do not mistake a wireless-compatible WheelyBird 3.0 or Fowl Play for a bundle with a remote; the Flyway 80 is the pick here with one included. A 50-clay magazine also does not eliminate all interaction: the manual Claymore still needs a pedal step for each throw. Finally, avoid choosing by advertised maximum distance alone. The release position, clay fit, safe shooting area and between-shot effort determine whether a thrower works for your actual practice. (doalloutdoors.com)
Frequently Asked Questions
Which pick lets one person throw clays without a battery?
The Caldwell Claymore Solo is the lighter foot-operated choice, but you load each new target. The larger Caldwell Claymore holds 50 targets and uses pedal-operated cocking and release, trading easier magazine loading for a heavier machine.
Which selected thrower includes a wireless remote?
The Do All Outdoors Flyway 80 includes one, with a manufacturer-stated range of 300 feet. Champion lists a remote as a separate accessory for WheelyBird 3.0; Fowl Play is remote-compatible but its listed kit includes a corded pedal.
Can these throwers launch doubles?
Caldwell explicitly identifies single and double throws for the Claymore Solo, and Champion identifies doubles among the SkyBird tripod’s supported presentations. Do not infer doubles capability from an auto-feed machine’s magazine size.
Will mini or midi clays fit an auto-feed machine?
Check the exact feeder before buying. Caldwell documents standard, midi and mini clays for the manual Claymore Solo. Champion documents 108mm standard and 110mm international clays for both selected WheelyBird models; those specifications do not establish mini or midi compatibility.
Final Recommendation
Choose the Caldwell Claymore Solo 4002777 if you want one portable, battery-free thrower for varied solo practice, including doubles, and do not mind loading between throws. For longer auto-feed sessions, choose the Champion WheelyBird 3.0 40927 instead: its 60-target magazine and corded pedal reduce interruptions, provided you can supply its specified battery. If an included wireless remote matters more, the Do All Outdoors Flyway 80 FW80 is the better fit.